Despite appearing cheerful during a recent family trip to Orlando, Holly Willoughby is reportedly experiencing significant stress behind the scenes. Sources close to the presenter reveal that she is struggling with the prospect of hosting Strictly Come Dancing, a role that could mark a major return to primetime television.

As previously reported, the 44-year-old television star is being considered as a potential replacement for Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman. BBC insiders say they have long hoped to recruit her for the popular entertainment series. However, according to a source, Holly is hesitant about accepting the role. “Holly’s Strictly talks are in full swing. This could be her big comeback,” the insider explained. “But she’s second-guessing it. People think she’s thick-skinned, but the online criticism has taken a toll. She’s questioning her place in the industry and feels pressured about making the wrong move.”

The source added that while Strictly represents a significant career opportunity, Holly is cautious about the timing, public reaction, and the demands it would place on her family. “She knows what the show could do for her career but is unsure if she’s ready to step back into the spotlight while still rebuilding her confidence,” they said.

Holly is also dealing with a separate legal challenge. She and her husband, Dan Baldwin, co-own Roxy Media, which is facing a dispute over an unpaid tax bill of £377,000. The company was given three months to settle the debt in April or face closure. Legal proceedings have been delayed due to complications involving former accountants, with the appeal now scheduled for November 12. While Holly and Dan are not expected to attend the hearing, insiders say the situation has weighed heavily on her. “Roxy Media was their joint project, but it’s now a source of added stress,” a source said.

Amid these pressures, Holly recently took a family trip to Orlando, which she shared on Instagram with her 8.1 million followers. She was accompanied by Dan and their three children, as well as friends including Abbey Clancy, Peter Crouch, and Denise van Outen. The trip, however, attracted criticism online, with some accusing her of being out of touch for promoting the holiday while many families cannot afford such experiences.

This period comes after several challenging years for the presenter. Her long-term friendship with Phillip Schofield ended following revelations of his affair in 2023. She also stepped away from her 14-year role on This Morning after a serious security threat, and recent projects such as Dancing On Ice and Celebrity Bear Hunt were discontinued. Additionally, she left her co-hosting role on You Bet! but will remain on the show as a panellist.

While hosting Strictly could offer a brighter professional path, Holly remains uncertain about her future. “She’s torn about her next steps and questions whether returning to primetime TV is worth it,” the insider added. “Holly’s happy place isn’t where it used to be, and she’s considering whether the spotlight is right for her at this time.”