In a heartfelt new interview with People magazine published on January 31, 2026, Hayley, 31, opened up about her future on the iconic ABC show for the first time since welcoming her first child—a baby girl named Everley—with husband and DWTS judge Derek Hough last month. Fresh off her miraculous recovery from a life-threatening cranial hematoma in 2023 that required emergency brain surgery, Hayley revealed she’s keeping the door wide open for a potential return, declaring: “Never say never.”

The candid confession has sent fans into a frenzy, reigniting hope that one of the show’s most inspiring figures could grace the ballroom again—whether as a pro dancer, a guest performer, or even in a surprise comeback role. But Hayley was quick to acknowledge the complications, citing a potential “conflict of interest” with Derek serving as a judge. “Lots of my friends have gone back after having kids,” she told the outlet, “but it’s a little difficult with [Derek] being a judge. Might be a little bit of a conflict of interest.”

She added with her trademark optimism: “But I do know that I want to dance. I want to keep moving. We will see if my body is ready to do the whole show… If the timing and the circumstances ever felt right in the future, I would absolutely be open to stepping back into that world in whatever way made sense. Maybe I’m just in a number. Who knows?”

The interview marks a triumphant chapter in Hayley’s extraordinary journey—one that has seen her overcome devastating health setbacks, embrace motherhood, and reaffirm her passion for the art form that has defined her life.

A Shocking Medical Scare That Nearly Ended Her Dancing Dreams

Hayley’s road to this moment has been anything but easy. In December 2023, during a performance on Derek’s Symphony of Dance tour, she suddenly collapsed backstage after suffering a burst blood vessel in her brain, leading to a cranial hematoma—a life-threatening condition requiring immediate emergency craniectomy surgery to remove part of her skull and relieve pressure on her brain.

The ordeal was terrifying. Hayley spent weeks in intensive care, underwent multiple surgeries, and faced an uncertain future. Doctors warned that her mobility, speech, and ability to dance might never fully return. Yet, in a display of sheer determination, she fought back. By mid-2024, she was walking again, then slowly returning to light movement, and eventually performing a poignant encore routine with Derek on Dancing With the Stars Season 33—her first time back on the ballroom floor since retiring from the troupe in 2019.

Fans watched in tears as she danced with grace and resilience, proving that miracles do happen. “It was emotional,” Hayley later shared. “But it felt right. Dancing saved me in so many ways.”

Motherhood, Marriage, and the Next Chapter

Fast-forward to late 2025, and Hayley welcomed baby Everley with Derek—a joyful milestone that has shifted her priorities. In the People interview, she and Derek discussed balancing parenthood with their demanding careers. Derek, a six-time Mirrorball champion turned judge, praised Hayley’s strength: “She’s incredible. Motherhood suits her, but her passion for dance never fades.”

Hayley echoed that sentiment, saying she’s “enjoying every moment” with their daughter while planning to resume touring with Derek on the Symphony of Dance: Encore in June 2026. “I want Everley to see us dancing, to grow up around that energy,” she said. “But right now, family comes first.”

The couple’s love story has long been a fan favourite. Hayley joined DWTS as a troupe member in 2015, where she met Derek. Their chemistry was undeniable, leading to a romance that blossomed into marriage in 2022. Through highs (multiple Mirrorball wins for Derek) and lows (Hayley’s health crisis), they’ve remained a united front.

Why Fans Are Begging for Her Return

Hayley’s potential comeback has ignited excitement among DWTS loyalists. As a troupe dancer from 2015-2019, she never partnered with a celebrity but became a standout for her technical precision, emotional performances, and infectious positivity. Her absence during Derek’s judging tenure has left a void—fans often call for her to return as a pro or guest.

“Hayley deserves to shine again,” one viewer commented on social media. “Her story is inspiring—health scare, baby, and still ready to dance? Iconic!” Others speculate a guest spot or even a pro role could happen, especially with the show’s evolving format.

But Hayley remains pragmatic. “It’s not just about me—it’s about timing, family, and what’s best for everyone,” she told People. “Derek being a judge adds a layer. We don’t want any perception of bias.”

Derek’s Take: Supportive Husband and Judge

Derek, who joined the judging panel in 2023, has been vocal about wanting Hayley back in some capacity. In a joint interview, he said: “If she wants to dance, I’ll be her biggest cheerleader. Whether it’s a number, a tour, or even the ballroom—whatever feels right.”

The couple’s upcoming tour will feature new choreography, family-friendly elements, and perhaps a nod to their DWTS roots. “We’re excited,” Hayley said. “It’s a way to share our love of dance with Everley watching from the wings one day.”

The Legacy of Hayley Erbert Hough on DWTS

Hayley’s impact on Dancing With the Stars extends beyond her troupe days. Her 2024 return performance was one of the season’s most emotional moments, symbolizing resilience. Producers have hinted at future guest spots for beloved alumni, and with ratings strong, a Hayley cameo could be a ratings goldmine.

For now, she’s content with motherhood and recovery. “I’ve learned life can change in an instant,” she reflected. “Dance will always be part of me, but so will my family. I’m open to whatever comes next.”

Never say never—words that perfectly capture Hayley Erbert Hough’s unbreakable spirit. Whether she steps back into the ballroom full-time, performs a special number, or simply inspires from the sidelines, one thing is clear: the DWTS icon isn’t done dancing yet.

Fans will be watching closely as spring 2026 approaches. Could Hayley Erbert Hough make a triumphant return? The ballroom doors are open… and the glitterball is waiting.