Public officials should be scrutinised over the abuse and murder of adopted baby Preston Davey, coroner urges
Public officials must be scrutinised over the abuse and murder of adopted baby Preston Davey, a coroner has urged.
Speaking at Blackpool Coronerâs Court on Monday, senior coroner for Blackpool and Fylde, Alan Wilson, said it was âhighly likelyâ an inquest would be held into 13-month-old Prestonâs death â but no final decision has been made yet.
Preston was nine months old when he was adopted by predator Jamie Varley, 37, and his partner, 32-year-old John McGowan-Fazakerley.
He had been taken from his mother, convicted murderer Sarah Davey, by an emergency care order by Oldham Council and placed into foster care at five days old.
Across a period of four months, Varley and McGowan-Fazakerley subjected the infant to physical, sexual and emotional abuse until his death on July 27 2023.
Following an eight-week trial at Preston Crown Court, Varley was handed a whole life term last month for the abuse and final, fatal sexual assault committed against the infant.
McGowan-Fazakerley was handed 25 years for his role in the abuse and his complicity in allowing Varleyâs campaign of crimes.
The court heard how the couple, who lived in Blackpool, used Preston as their âplaythingâ, with the infant suffering âunremitting abuseâ of sex assaults and physical attacks.
Jamie Varley, 37, (left) was was given a whole life order for the murder of Preston Davey and his boyfriend, John McGowan-Fazakerley, 32, (right) was sentenced to 25 years
Preston Davey, who died aged 13 months, was smothered and sexually assaulted
The men had brought Preston to Blackpool Victoria Hospital on three occasions before his murder, where he was seen by a âbattery of professionalsâ including medical staff, social workers and welfare officers from various bodies.
No further action was taken.
Speaking at the hearing, Mr Wilson said an inquest was initially opened following Prestonâs death, but this was later suspended while police investigated and trials were ultimately held.
He said he had to consider if the inquest should continue given the ârelevant issuesâ already heard during the criminal trial.
Yet while Mr Wilson confirmed a final decision has not been made, subject to submissions from lawyers for other public bodies, it was âhighly likelyâ an inquiry would take place â probably in autumn next year.
He said: âI feel thereâs sufficient reason to resume. There are acts and omissions of public authorities that need to be scrutinised in a public hearing in which Prestonâs family can participate.
âItâs clearly going to be a wide-ranging inquiry.â
Mr Wilson added he was aware calls had been made for a public inquiry but his role meant it was not a matter for himself to consider, rather to proceed on the basis of whether or not to hold an inquest.
Preston Daveyâs short, tragic life was bookmarked by murder, by his mother and then his adoptive parents
Preston Davey with birth mother Sarah Davey, who carried out a horrific crime as a teenager
The court heard a review into Prestonâs death by Oldham Safeguarding Childrenâs Partnership has resumed following its suspension while Varley and McGowan-Fazakerleyâs trial took place.
The review is expected to be complete by next January and it was confirmed an inquest could bot go ahead until then.
The hearing went on to address which people and public bodies â including Prestonâs biological mother and grandmother â should be legally represented at any inquest.
Prestonâs mother Sarah and grandmother Debbie Davey were not present in court but were represented by lawyers.
Preston was born while Sarah was in custody and a place in a mother and baby unit in the prison was refused.
Instead, he was taken from her by a court order from Oldham Council and placed with temporary adoptive parents before being adopted by Varley and McGowan.
Sarah has been in and out of jail after being handed a mandatory life sentence for murder in July 1999.
She and 15-year-old Lisa Healey had befriended and murdered a frail pensioner before stuffing her body into a bin and throwing it in Rochdale Canal.
Adoption Now, the service responsible for Prestonâs adoption, were represented at Mondayâs hearing alongside Bolton Council, who were described as the âhostâ council for the body.
It was heard that while Oldham Council managed Prestonâs adoption, Bolton Council also a had a role.
Also present at the hearing were lawyers for Prestonâs father Gary Nolan and legal representatives for the NHS trust running Blackpool Victoria Hospital.
It is yet to be decided whether South Shore Academy, the high school where Varley worked, should be involved in the inquest.
Also undecided is whether Lancashire Police should have lawyers representing the force at an inquest.
The trial heard their officers were called after Preston was first taken to hospital suffering injuries and safeguarding concerns were raised but no further action was taken.
Mr Wilson adjourned for a further hearing to be held in October, telling Prestonâs father: âPlease accept everyoneâs condolences. Iâm conscious we are approaching his anniversary.â